REPORT ON PREDATORY LENDING PREVENTION TRAINING SEMINARS

When the predatory lending prevention educational program was launched over four years ago, our primary focus was on the traditionally vulnerable populations on Long Island, particularly low-to-middle income and minority homebuyers. As the program expanded, we began to discover entirely new types of vulnerable populations, including seniors who were victims of home improvement scams, newly arrived immigrants, and young people who needed help learning how to manage their finances. To our surprise, these vulnerable populations also attend middle class congregations and live in middle class neighborhoods.

Over the past six to eight months we have received increasing numbers of requests from emerging market such as immigrants who require special financial instruments consistent with their faith traditions and cultural preferences. In addition to faith based groups from larger denominations, houses of worship requesting the workshops have also become more diverse, ranging from Pentecostal churches to non-English-speaking groups and newly arrived immigrants. As predatory lenders develop new ways of fleecing both traditional and emerging markets, we are developing responses to help our attendees avoid dangerous traps and are providing them access to reputable methods of financing.

We begin each workshop with a welcome from our host. Our executive director, the Rev. Tom Goodhue, or another LICC staff person, is usually the emcee. He introduces the panelists, followed by a representative from a not-for-profit organization who can address issues where those with no vested interest will have more credibility-such as how to shop for a loan. We save the bulk of our time for questions from the audience-and give them a chance to ask questions anonymously in writing. We invite every financial institution that partners with us, whether or not their representative is present, to distribute literature, and we encourage the audience to talk individually with representatives from regulated financial institutions, although we do not steer attendees to any particular institution.

We are also helping legitimate lenders learn how to serve emerging markets. In June of 2006, we conducted our first workshop for financial professionals who wish to work with emerging populations. The workshop was held at the Islamic Center of Long Island in Westbury. Seventeen financial professionals attended (Bank of America sent folks all the way from Baltimore!), all of whom said that the seminar was very helpful to them in understanding how to better serve Muslim Americans. Here are some insights we gained from that session:

  • Because relatively few Muslims work in banks hereabouts, Muslim-American customers are likely to feel somewhat uncomfortable with bankers.

  • At least two distinct approaches to financing home-buying have been taken by Muslim-Americans, the murabaha pioneered by HSBC (in which the prospective homeowner gives a bank a "promise to purchase," the bank buys the home, and the bank then resells it over time to the new owner) and the ijara program pioneered by Guidance Financial (which is essentially a rent-to-own co-ownership). Murabaha payments qualify for income tax deductions.

  • The Qu'ran may prohibit interest payments but makes an exception if you need to borrow money to survive - and some Muslims in America see home ownership as a practical necessity for survival here. Some experts in Shari'a (Islamic law) believe that the prohibition on borrowing and lending does not apply to home mortgages, anyway, since this is a form of long-term investment rather than borrowing money for frivolous spending.

  • Since not all Muslims interpret Shari'a the same way, it is important for financial professionals to ask customers, "What would you be comfortable doing?"

  • Banks and insurance companies and other financial institutions are more likely to sell investments to Muslim Americans if they both meet social/ethical investing screens (such as a "social" equity fund that avoids alcohol stocks) and if any interest earned on the investment-as opposed to gains-can be clearly identified, since many Muslims donate to charity any incidental interest they earn. Most Muslims would avoid most bond funds, but municipal bonds may be acceptable, since they are intended for the good of the community. Again, it is important for finance professionals to ask, "What would you be most comfortable doing?"

  • Islam does not require purity. Muslims do not expect every minute aspect of a mutual fund to conform to Shari'a. Mother Theresa said something similar when she remarked, "God doesn't ask me to be perfect, only to be faithful."

  • Intent is extremely important in Muslim ethics, as it is in Catholic moral reasoning. "I am not responsible for the outcome of my decisions," one of our speakers said, "but it is my responsibility to try to do good."

The only complaint, voiced by nearly half of the participants, was that they wished the program could have gone on longer. We also thought it would be helpful in future seminars for Muslims to explore insurance issues further, for example: Does the Qu'ran address insurance? Would Muslims want to avoid PMI? Would whole-life insurance policies have to be scrutinized as to whether the investment met ethical/social screening criteria?

On Sunday, October 1st we hosted a financial seminar for a youth group at the First Church of God in Elmont. This was a congregation of recently arrived immigrant East Asians, primarily from India, who worship in Malayalam and English, although we conducted the seminar in English. The focus was on how newly arrived populations can establish relationships with reputable financial professionals, and how to manage money including how to save, budget, manage credit, and how wisely to prioritize spending decisions.

We are also receiving numerous requests for workshops in Spanish and English such as the First Presbyterian Church in Southold where we conducted simultaneous presentations in English for seniors and in Spanish for Latinos including several day laborers. Christ Lutheran Church in Freeport and First Presbyterian Church in Freeport are also planning simultaneous seminars in Spanish and English.

We are negotiating additional seminars, including one for one for domestic violence survivors, and several for Catholic Charities at multiple sites. And we are gearing up for what we fear may become a very serious problem not only on Long Island but throughout the country: How do the millions of people who bought homes with Adjustable Rate Mortgages cope with the impending upward adjustments of their loan payments?

We are grateful to the following institutions for their financial support and for their representatives who generously volunteer their time to help us conduct these workshops:

  • Astoria Federal Savings
  • Bank of America
  • Citibank
  • Dime Savings Bank of New York
  • GreenPoint Bank
  • JPMorgan Chase
  • Long Island Housing Partnership
  • Long Island Housing Services
  • Ridgewood Savings Bank
  • Wells Fargo Home Mortgage

A special thanks goes to John Bendick, a real estate appraiser who lives in Cutchogue and drove all the way to Valley Stream to speak to seniors on a Saturday evening. A special thanks also goes to Rich Murphy of Wells Fargo Home Mortgage for helping us identify emerging issues the program should be addressing and how to help religious leaders of all faith traditions in our region identify what the predatory lending prevention needs are in their own communities. Rich had the following wisdom to impart regarding the special needs of young people:

"It is my belief that, in general, we have failed to teach the [financial] basics to our children . . . they need to [understand] basic functions such as proper and effective use of credit cards and the consequences of misuse, how to apply for basic loans (car, tuition, etc.), and most importantly, how to save money. Americans today seem incapable of saving money. We spend recklessly. This is evident at all levels, among people of all religions, all ethnic backgrounds, all levels of education - and our biggest, most visible example is our government.

"I've been shouting for years that we need to return to the basics: re-instituting student savings accounts at the elementary school level, and teaching budgeting and financial awareness in the middle schools and high schools. There have been a number of finance seminars held at the college level that have had enormous attendance."

Additional emerging concerns that Rich has identified are the risks of taking out Option ARMS, Negative ARMS and Interest-only ARMS. He is also helping us develop a program to respond to predatory lending "pay day loan sharks" and unscrupulous "rescue specialists" who prey upon the vulnerable and unwary whatever their socioeconomic status.

We received a $2,000 grant in the Fall of 2006 to develop an alternative pay day loan program for clients at risk. We are also exploring the possibility of alternative mortgage refinancing to help our clients who are in danger of foreclosure.

Home | About | Contact | Programs | Reports | Giving | Ecumenical | Privacy | Leadership | News | The Prelude | Photo Gallery
copyright 2005